All content on this blog from Tim McGhee has moved to the Tim McGhee Substack, and soon, Lord willing, will be found only on that Substack.

Saturday, January 3, 2004

File Sharers: Don't Crow Yet: "As a ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., points out, technology races so far ahead of judges and legislators that it's hard to know when using software, hardware and digital networks to copy intellectual property is, or should be, a crime.

"The decision last month—barring record companies from forcing Internet service providers to reveal the names of alleged music swappers—was, on its face, a victory for consumer privacy rights."

"Before the ruling, the RIAA simply had to request a subpoena from any U.S. district court clerk's office. Now, it must prove to a judge that it has sufficient evidence before naming any individual in a lawsuit and obtaining a subpoena. The judges drew useful distinctions between legitimate and excessive legal actions to defend property. The court, in effect, said the situation was analogous to letting a retailer safeguard its clothes with electronic tags and door guards but forbidding it to sneak into houses to find blouses without receipts."

The judges mostly punted the gnarly issue to Congress, holding, "It is not the province of the courts … to rewrite [copyright law] in order to make it fit a new and unforeseen Internet architecture, no matter how damaging that development has been to the music industry."

"When work began on the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, which laid the legal foundation for fighting digital piracy, lawmakers had no idea that file-sharing, MP3 players and other digital innovations would be so popular. The act, thus, has little useful to say about what sort of copying constitutes fair use.

"That's why Congress should stop digging its head into the silicon and confront an issue it hasn't for years. Sen. Orrin G. Hatch (R-Utah) should make good on his recent promise to herd the unruliest industry folks around a table and compel them to develop ways to take advantage of—rather than just try to halt—technology."

No comments:

Blog Archive